Who do you agree with this time? NL vs CreekMM

new123

I am not trying to bash anyone. Both NL and CreekMM are great EW/GANN masters. However, I am really concerned that they have very different prediction where the market will go in the mid-term. NL laoda perdicts that consolidation is over and market will most likely rebound for several weeks. The strategy is buy in dip. However, CreekMM laoda predicts that market will crash soon and SPX possibly go to 700-740 on 02/20-21, which is only two weeks away. I just want to know what my fellow HTers are thinking.

SpringMountain

does big P's theory apply here?

Maylin

Market is not going to crash but a pull back is due.  MMs will unload when retailors like us are rushing into the market.  Better be careful!!!

biorjin

pt6

干嘛不直接调牛，熊，猪，非要把NL和主席绕进去。可能这样更能刺激下注。相信你没其他的意思，只是想知道群众的想法。

creekmm

我有自己倾向的同时，并不排除NL老师所说的可能性，本身预测都是一种可能性而已。

操作重于预测。

bluefish

没看出有攻击任何人的意思。
调查而已。
RBC 的动能报告显示  中期动能开始向下。

dzhxs3

干嘛不直接调牛，熊，猪，非要把NL和主席绕进去。可能这样更能刺激下注。相信你没其他的意思，只是想知道群众的想法。
pt6 发表于 2009-2-8 16:43

purety

这种帖子还是删了吧
纯粹找茬

Persistance

biorjin 发表于 2009-2-8 15:28

Agree!  Bear market, cautious is required all the time.

Brainteaser

暗觉的哈, 还是仓位决定同意谁, 这样的统计, 真的没有啥意思

benmao

大盘是走出来的, 边看,边想,边放...

老大大盖都是有PLAN A,PLAN B的吧???

Elephant

我选择赞同主席的,但是觉得主席的东西太粗枝大叶,起码21/2是周六,他也不仔细研究.

q13117

I suggest it is better to remove this kind of post. It does not make sense. Both high hands Naturalaw and creekmm should highly respected when they spend so much time to do a lot of analysis and share their analysis to all of us.

Teddy

I suggest it is better to remove this kind of post. It does not make sense. Both high hands Naturalaw and creekmm should highly respected when they spend so much time to do a lot of analysis and share ...
q13117 发表于 2009-2-8 21:36

agree 100%~~~~

一枪一个

如果是纯技术上的讨论，倒也没有bash谁的意思。主席的第一种case，也是说反弹还会持续一段时间，跟NL并不矛盾。我个人对盘面的感觉是还有一定的上升空间。

2brakefirst

I am not trying to bash anyone. Both NL and CreekMM are great EW/GANN masters. However, I am really concerned that they have very different prediction where the market will go in the mid-term. NL laod ...
new123 发表于 2009-2-8 14:20

有意思。NL 和 CreekMM 都是Gann 学派专家，没想到这波预测趋势倾向却相反。

zhishun

俺还是选择观望。不过主席的可能性好像更大一些。
现在这市场，高手都有分歧，小弟还是靠边站。